Read: March 2009
This is the second in the quartet from Stephanie Meyer that starts with Twilight. I knew this book would along the same lines as Twilight, as so I was prepared for it not being the most interesting or challenging read, but wanted to read it as other colleagues had and had enjoyed the series.
I got really annoyed at the first quarter of this book, because it was basically Bella moping and being depressed as her love Edward had left. I found this really annoying and it didn't make me like the character any more. I'm sure that I'd feel differently if I was a teenage girl, and this would seem SO true to life, but for me it just got on my nerves that she couldn't see a life beyond a crush.
The book got better in the second quarter when Bella started being better friends with Jake. Jake had been a friend growing up and lives nearby. I found that their friendship felt really genuine. Jake feels a natural character, and their scenes together ring true - they are written nicely as two teenagers who are family friends and have grown up together.
But just as I thought the book was getting better, Edward returns and he and Bella go on an adventure together. Bella just totally forgets Jake and abandons him to SAVE Edward. I was disappointed that the story went back to blinded teenage romance where nothing else matters and this person is the only person you care about and you don't think that there might be any other way of living. The book also ended with Bella again pleading to be turned into a vampire, which also annoyed me.
I really forced myself to finish reading this book, as I really didn't agree with what happened in the second half. I told my colleague that I hadn't enjoyed this book as much, and she agreed that this was the weakest book, but that things improved. I hoped so....
Read:May 2009
After my annoyance at New Moon I decided to do a double entry for these two books, as I didn't think I would have much to say. Having said that, I did enjoy Eclipse more than New Moon. Mainly because Jake had a really good and central role, where his character could not only develop, but, in my opinion, really rival Edward.
Jake's character really grew in this book and the friendship between him and Bella also developed into something strong. I think that Bella starts to fall for Jake, and I think that she is right to do so, as his character is much more an even to Bella, than Edward. Jake seems more "healthy" for Bella, than a blinkered relationship with Edward.
The twist in this book was that Jake, and others on the reservation, have turned into werewolves. This was actually a great twist, as the vampires and the werewolves are enemies and won't go onto each others land. The story takes a nice turn in that the vampires and the werewolves have to work together to defend the land and look after Bella. Even as a wolf, Jake retains his humour and friendliness and this really endeared him to me. It was actually quite fun to see him and Edward compete for Bella's attention and she becomes genuinely torn between them, as they offer her something significant. I was glad that Jake was so open about his feelings, to try and convince Bella to go for him instead of Edward. I don't know if I'd have been able to do the same. Even though it doesn't end in Jake's favour, he gave it his best shot.
As you can probably tell, I probably enjoyed this book more than the others so far - mainly as Jake's character could develop and provided some light relief and realism to the whole thing. Annoyingly though, in the final part of the book, Bella again pleaded to be turned into a vampire. Edward is not keen to turn Bella, as he feels that a human life is more valuable than one as a vampire and that he and his family did not have a choice, when Bella does. Edward tries to warn Bella that if she is turned, this cannot be reversed and therefore it is a huge decision, but she is adamant that Edward is THE ONE and she wants to be with him forever (do you really meet THE ONE when you are 15? Do you really know you have met THE ONE when you are 15?). Edward is more cautious and asks her to marry him. His reasoning being that if she will marry him, then they have already made a commitment to be together forever. I had to laugh when Bella wouldn't agree to marry Edward, but was still insistent that she wanted to be turned. She said herself that it wasn't right to marry so young, but again was insistent that she knew she wanted to be turned. In the end Bella does agree to marry Edward, but again remains very shy about it (not wanting to tell her parents or any of her friends). I guess here my feelings on marriage and lifelong commitment are coming through. If I knew someone was so reluctant about one type of commitment, then I would not be confident of their commitment in another area. I know this isn't real life, but has been written as a bit of teenage romance/fantasy fun, but I would bet against this lasting.
I've been promised that the final book is the best and will keep me awake all night turning the pages!